Crispen's Point

Christian otome visual novel. 2018. Romance set in a small American town.

The visual novel version of the book: https://www.amazon.com/Crispens-Point-Blackberry-County-Chronicles/dp/B00G79XNUM

Charlotte is a successful romance novelist who escapes city life and moves to the small town of Crispens Point in Blackberry County. She immediately connects with some of the quirky but friendly residents and begins to feel at home right away. When a friend invites her to attend a local community church, Charlotte is attracted to the pastor, but refuses to acknowledge that attraction because of some dark things in her past.

What is the mysterious thing in Charlotte's past that seems to dominate everything? Is it enough to keep her from ever finding a lasting relationship?